The square knot and the granny knot are made from the same two half knots. The difference is the direction of the second crossing. A square knot alternates the direction. A granny knot repeats the same crossing twice. That one change is why the square knot lies flat and holds steady, while the granny knot lumps, twists and can slip or jam.
How to tie each knot
Square knot
- Cross the left end over the right end, then tuck it under.
- Cross the right end over the left end, then tuck it under. This crossing runs the opposite way to the first.
- Pull both ends snug.
Granny knot
- Cross the left end over the right end, then tuck it under.
- Repeat the same crossing: left end over right end, then tuck it under again. Both crossings now run the same way.
- Pull both ends snug.
How the two behave
The square knot lies flat and looks balanced, and its two crossings mirror each other. It holds steady under a steady pull, although it is still a light-duty knot.
The granny knot is lopsided. It tends to lump and twist, and it can slip or jam, particularly under a sudden load. Pulled tight on thin cord, it can lock up and become hard to untie.
The shoelace test
The quickest everyday check is the bow. A square knot in shoelaces makes a flat bow that lies horizontally. A granny knot makes a bow that stands upright or sits crooked. If your bow stands up, you have probably tied a granny knot. Untie it and tie it again, making the second crossing run the other way.
Where you will meet the granny knot
Most granny knots are tied by accident. Someone tries for a square knot, repeats the same crossing and gets a lumpy knot instead. The granny knot is also known as the false knot, lubber’s knot or calf knot. You will often see it:
- On shoelaces and bows
- On ribbons and bow ties, where it gives a crooked look
- In quick, casual crafts, where a slip does not matter much
How to check your tie
Look at the two crossings. In a square knot, they mirror each other. In a granny knot, both run the same way. Then pull each end gently. A square knot should settle flat. A granny will often lump, twist or slide.
The thief knot is a related look-alike. Its two ends exit on opposite sides of the knot, which makes it even weaker. The square, granny and thief knots comparison covers it in more detail, along with the square knot guide.
What to use instead
Pick the knot for the job:
- Light binding, such as a parcel: a square knot, finished with a half hitch for security. The parcel string knot guide shows the wrap and the finish.
- Joining two lines: a sheet bend, which handles different diameters better than a square knot.
- Round or tight binding: the constrictor knot.
- Anything where a failure could cause harm: neither square nor granny. Use a knot taught for that job.
Safety note
Neither the square knot nor the granny knot should be used for heavy lifting, climbing, rigging or any job where a failure could injure someone. For those jobs, use a knot taught for the purpose by a qualified instructor, with rated equipment.