Binding Knots and Hitches

Square Knot vs Granny Knot vs Thief Knot, and Safer Alternatives

Square knot vs granny knot vs thief knot: how to tell them apart, why the granny and thief knots fail under load, and safer alternatives to use instead.

On this page
  1. Square knot vs. granny knot
  2. Thief knot
  3. Where you will still meet the granny knot
  4. Safer alternatives, by job
  5. Choosing a knot: a quick check
  6. Safety note

The square knot, the granny knot and the thief knot look alike at a glance. The square knot is the one to use for light binding. The granny knot slips, and the thief knot has little real strength, so neither is a good choice for anything that matters. This guide shows how to tell them apart, where you will still meet the granny knot, and which knots to choose instead.

Square knot vs. granny knot

The two knots use the same two half knots. The difference is in the second crossing. The square knot alternates the direction of the crossings. The granny knot repeats the same crossing twice.

That single difference changes how the knot behaves. The square knot lies flat and holds steady under a steady pull. The granny knot tends to lump and twist, and it can slip or jam. For a full walkthrough, see what is the difference between a square knot and a granny knot.

Thief knot

The thief knot looks like a square knot, but its two working ends exit on opposite sides of the knot instead of the same side. That small change removes most of its strength. It can slip and jam under load, so it is not a reliable knot.

Knot references often describe the thief knot as a tamper-evident knot, used on bags. The story goes that a thief who opened a bag tied this way and retied it with a familiar square knot would give themselves away. This is folklore, but it explains the name. Whatever its history, do not use it to hold anything that matters.

Where you will still meet the granny knot

Most granny knots are tied by accident. Someone tries for a square knot, repeats the same crossing, and ends up with a lumpy knot. The granny knot is also known as the false knot, lubber’s knot or calf knot.

You will often see it in these places:

  • Shoelaces and bows. A bow that stands upright instead of lying flat is usually a granny. The shoelace knots guide shows how to tie the bow square.
  • Ribbons and bow ties. The same upright, crooked look shows up here.
  • Quick, casual ties in crafts. Some people use it where a slip does not matter.

Be aware that a granny knot can jam when it is pulled tight, which makes it hard to untie. That is a reason to avoid it for anything you may need to undo later.

Safer alternatives, by job

Pick the alternative that matches the job:

  • Joining two lines of the same or different sizes: a sheet bend. It handles different diameters better than a square knot.
  • A permanent or long-term join: a double fisherman’s knot, which is a strong and reliable way to join two lines.
  • Joining heavy ropes or cables: the Carrick bend, a sailor’s bend that holds well on heavy line.
  • Parcels and bundles: a square knot finished with an extra half hitch, or the approach in the parcel string knot guide.
  • Round objects such as poles, bags and cylinders: the constrictor knot, which grips harder as you pull.
  • Slippery line that a square knot will not hold: the surgeon’s knot, which adds an extra pass in the first throw for more friction.

Choosing a knot: a quick check

  • Will the knot bear weight, or move under load? Do not use a square, granny or thief knot. Use a knot taught for that job, with rated equipment where it matters.
  • Are you joining two lines? Use a sheet bend or a double fisherman’s.
  • Are you binding something? Use a square knot with an extra half hitch for light work, or a constrictor for a tighter grip.
  • Can you check it? Tie it, then test with a gentle pull before you trust it.

Safety note

Knots that slip or jam can fail without warning. For climbing, lifting, towing or rigging, learn from a qualified instructor and use rated equipment. Do not rely on any knot in this guide for a job where a failure could injure someone.

The complete guide to binding knots and hitches

Square Knot (Reef Knot): How to Tie It and When to Use It
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →