Knot Basics

Shoelace Knots: Alternative Ways to Tie Your Shoes

Alternative shoelace knots that stay tied: Ian's secure knot, the surgeon's knot, and the runner's loop heel lock, with steps and when to use each.

On this page
  1. Start with a correct square bow
  2. Ian’s secure shoelace knot
  3. The surgeon’s knot
  4. The runner’s loop (heel lock)
  5. Which method to use
  6. Tips for laces that stay tied
  7. Frequently asked questions

Most people tie a standard bow, and it works well on everyday shoes. It can work loose on slippery laces, though, and a heel that lifts inside the shoe causes rubbing. This guide covers a correctly tied standard bow, two alternative knots that hold better, and the runner’s loop, which locks the heel in place.

Start with a correct square bow

Many shoes come undone because the bow was tied as a granny knot, with both crossings going the same way. A square (reef) knot reverses the second crossing, which keeps the bow balanced.

  1. Cross the laces and pull them tight. Pass the left lace over the right, then under and through the gap.
  2. Make a loop with each lace, one in each hand.
  3. Cross the loops the opposite way to the first crossing: right over left, then under and through the gap.
  4. Pull both loops, and tighten the bow evenly.

If the bow lies on its side or one loop is much bigger than the other, you have probably tied a granny knot. Undo it and start again.

Ian’s secure shoelace knot

Ian’s secure knot is a fast, symmetrical bow. Both loops pass through the same central opening, which creates a double wrap that grips the laces. Many runners use it, and it is often recommended for slippery round laces. Ian Fieggen’s shoelace site has illustrated steps. Practice on a pair of shoes you wear at home before you rely on it, because the steps are easy to mix up at first.

The surgeon’s knot

The surgeon’s knot starts with a double wrap instead of a single crossing. Cross the laces, wrap them around each other a second time, and pull tight before you finish the bow. The extra turn adds friction, so the knot suits boots, work shoes, and laces that slide. It is a little harder to untie than a standard bow.

The runner’s loop (heel lock)

The runner’s loop, also called a heel lock, keeps your heel from lifting inside the shoe. It uses the top pair of eyelets, so the shoe needs a spare eyelet above the last crossing.

  1. Lace normally up to the second-to-last pair of eyelets.
  2. For the top pair, feed the left lace down through the top eyelet on the left side, from the outside. A small loop forms inside the shoe.
  3. Do the same with the right lace on the right side.
  4. Cross the laces. Pass the left end through the right loop, and the right end through the left loop.
  5. Pull both ends down and outward to snug the collar around your heel.
  6. Tie a standard bow.

If your heel still lifts after this, the shoe may be too big for your foot, and no lacing method fully fixes that.

Which method to use

Method Best for Trade-off
Square bow, tied correctly Everyday shoes Can work loose on slippery laces
Ian’s secure knot Running, and round laces that slip Takes a little practice
Surgeon’s knot Boots, work shoes, slick laces Harder to untie
Runner’s loop Heel slip Needs a spare top eyelet

Tips for laces that stay tied

  • Waxed or textured flat laces grip better than slick round synthetic laces.
  • Tighten the crossing first, then pull the loops evenly. Yanking the loops can collapse the bow.
  • Match lace length to your number of eyelets. Laces that are too short will not form a bow, and laces that are too long drag and snag.

Frequently asked questions

Which shoelace knot is the most secure?

No single knot wins for every shoe. For most people, a square bow tied correctly works well. Use a surgeon’s knot or Ian’s secure knot if the bow keeps loosening, and add a runner’s loop if your heel slips.

What if I cannot untie a knot?

Work the knot loose a little at a time with a pick or a blunt tool, rather than pulling harder. Our guide to untying a tight knot covers the methods.

Can I tie shoelaces with one hand?

Yes. Our one-handed knots guide explains methods for when one hand is busy.

The complete guide to knot basics

Best Knots to Learn: A Beginner's Guide to Knot Tying
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →